Behavioral Economics and Decision Science: Belief, Influence, and Choice
Subliminal advertising is often presented as a way to steer people without their awareness. A Queen Mary University of London study led by Dr Magda Osman instead asked what people think such influence looks like, and whether they believe it would compromise their own choices. The distinction matters: the study reports beliefs and judgments, not an experiment on the effectiveness of subliminal messages [1].
This is a useful case for behavioral economics and decision science, fields concerned with how people make choices and how judgments can depart from idealized accounts of fully informed, consistently rational decision-making. Here, the object of study is not whether an advertisement changes a purchase, but how people reason about influence, agency, and vulnerability. The findings can inform questions about public understanding, but they cannot by themselves establish a causal effect on buying or voting.
What Is Behavioral Economics?
Behavioral economics combines ideas from economics and psychology to study decisions as they occur in real human settings. It considers how attention, context, expectations, emotion, habit, and limited information can shape choices. Decision science is a broader interdisciplinary effort to understand how people judge options and act; it draws on psychology, economics, statistics, and related fields. These approaches do not assume that every choice is irrational. Rather, they investigate the processes and conditions that make decisions understandable.
The Queen Mary research fits this wider interest in judgment because it asked participants to identify situations they considered manipulative and to assess how much those situations might affect free choice. It did not measure brain activity, test a hidden-message campaign, or compare actual purchases and votes. So it offers evidence about perceived influence, not direct evidence about the biological mechanisms of decision-making or the behavioral success of advertising [1].
That boundary is essential when discussing terms such as unconscious influence. A person may describe an effect as operating outside awareness; the description is not proof that a specific message had an unconscious effect. Researchers need measures suited to the claim—such as controlled exposure and behavioral outcomes—before concluding that a technique changed behavior.
What the Study Asked and Found
The researchers first asked volunteers in the UK, US, Canada, and Australia to give everyday examples of situations in which they felt their behavior had been manipulated without their knowledge. Almost half the examples concerned marketing or advertising. Seven percent were associated with politics, particularly campaign techniques intended to affect voting behavior [1].
A separate group of participants then assessed the examples and judged how far free choice would be affected. According to the report, participants believed psychological research was used in advertising and political settings to manipulate unconscious behavior, yet they generally felt able to retain free choice in purchasing or voting decisions. They judged therapeutic examples, including hypnotherapy and placebo treatments, as having a greater effect on unconscious behavior and as leaving less room for conscious choice [1].
These are judgments about scenarios. The contrast does not show that therapy actually overrides choice, or that marketing and political persuasion do not affect behavior. Nor does it establish how representative the participants were of everyone in the four countries. The study’s contribution, as presented in the report, is a map of examples and perceived control.
Dr Osman described the results as showing that subliminal advertising remains a topic of popular fascination, alongside limited understanding of the concept. Participants reportedly supplied detailed descriptions and concrete examples [1]. That combination is notable: people can have vivid ideas about a phenomenon even when those ideas do not amount to reliable evidence about its operation.
Marketing Claims and the Story of Hidden Influence
The report describes a market for services that promise to influence people below conscious awareness. One example was the Wrap, which claimed in 2013, on behalf of UKIP, that it could analyse voters’ brains to help create advertisements operating below conscious awareness [1]. This account establishes that such a claim was made; it does not demonstrate that the service worked or that voters were changed by it.
Marketing theorist Robert Lull, quoted in the report, argued that subliminal advertising thrives as a belief, while contemporary data-driven campaigning may rely on visible forms of persuasion rather than hidden messages [1]. This is commentary, not a result of the participant study. It helps distinguish a public narrative about secret influence from the many overt ways campaigns and companies can target audiences.
The report also recalls cultural sources of the hidden-persuasion story: Vance Packard’s 1950s book The Persuaders, Wilson B. Cutlip’s 1966 column on “invisible persuasion,” and a 2007 Fastonline claim that a UK supermarket had planted an Easter-egg image in shoppers’ minds. The last story was later widely described as a hoax, according to the report [1]. These historical references help explain how the idea circulated; they are not evidence that subliminal advertising produces reliable effects.
Keeping this history in one place avoids treating repeated anecdotes as independent confirmation. The presence of a story in public discussion, or a company’s claim about its service, is evidence of attention and belief—not proof of successful manipulation.
Perceived Susceptibility and Political Judgment
Participants judged themselves less susceptible to subliminal influence than other people [1]. This is a finding about self-assessment. It does not show that the participants were objectively more resistant, that other people were more vulnerable, or that the difference changed anyone’s ballot or shopping decision.
One cautious interpretation is that people may find it easier to imagine influence affecting others than themselves. But the report does not establish why participants made this distinction. It may reflect confidence in personal agency, how scenarios were understood, or other factors; these possibilities would need direct testing. The safest conclusion is simply that perceived susceptibility differed between self and others in the reported judgments.
Political choices make the question especially salient because voters encounter messages from campaigns, news, social networks, and advocacy groups. These forms of communication can be persuasive without being subliminal. A claim about targeted advertising, emotional framing, or repeated exposure should therefore be assessed on its own evidence rather than folded into a general story about unconscious control. The study documents participants’ beliefs about political influence, but it does not evaluate campaign data science or establish effects on voting [1].
What the Findings Can—and Cannot—Support
The report supports a limited set of conclusions: many volunteered examples related to marketing, a smaller share to politics, participants attributed unconscious influence to these contexts, and they still judged themselves able to retain choice in purchasing and voting. Participants also viewed themselves as less susceptible than others [1].
It does not show that subliminal advertising changes behavior, that people are immune to influence, or that beliefs about manipulation cannot be corrected. The latter claims would require separate evidence. Likewise, this study does not speak to habit formation or to dual brain circuits; those are distinct research topics, not mechanisms established by this survey of beliefs. References such as “Predicting human decisions with behavioral theories” (1904.06866v1) or “Dual Brain Circuits Drive Habit Formation” should not be treated as evidence for this article’s specific claim unless their findings are independently examined in relevant research.
A practical lesson for media literacy is to separate three questions: What persuasion technique is being claimed? What evidence shows it was used? And what evidence demonstrates an effect on actual choices? This framework applies to marketing and political communication alike. It also preserves a meaningful distinction between people’s experience of being influenced and verified causal effects.
Behavioral economics and decision science are valuable here not because they automatically explain hidden persuasion, but because they encourage careful study of judgments and choices in context. The Queen Mary study adds evidence about public beliefs and perceived agency. Its scope is informative precisely when it is not stretched into a claim that subliminal advertising works—or that it does not.
Source
[1] Neuroscience News, “People think marketing and political campaigns use psychology to influence their behaviors,” reporting research led by Dr Magda Osman, Queen Mary University of London: https://neurosciencenews.com/political-marketing-behavior-psychology-15353/
behavioral economics and decision science